New York vs South Dakota: Tax Impact on Your Salary
VSDetailed comparison of tax rates, cost of living, and quality of life
📌 Running the numbers on $75,000 shows 8.82% versus no income tax creates about $6,615 in take-home difference. South Dakota stays competitive by offering no income tax. Recent migration data indicates finance pros moving toward South Dakota, while rural lovers increasingly choose New York.
Looking at the numbers, New York's 8.82% rate versus South Dakota's no income tax means about $6,615 difference annually on $75,000. That's the kind of gap that gets people's attention, even if other factors ultimately drive the decision.
🔑 Key Differences
- **State income tax**: New York at 8.82% vs South Dakota at no income tax
- **Annual savings** (on $75,000): South Dakota saves you ~$6,615
- **Tax system**: Both use progressive brackets
- **Deductions**: Standard federal deductions apply, state variations exist
- **Local taxes**: Check your specific county/city as rates vary within states
Tax Comparison
| Tax Type | New York | South Dakota |
|---|---|---|
| State Income Tax | 4% - 8.82% | No Income Tax Winner |
| 💰 On $40,000 Salary |
State Tax: $2,564
Take Home: $37,436
|
State Tax: $0
Take Home: $40,000
+$2,564
|
| 💰 On $60,000 Salary |
State Tax: $3,846
Take Home: $56,154
|
State Tax: $0
Take Home: $60,000
+$3,846
|
| 💰 On $100,000 Salary |
State Tax: $6,410
Take Home: $93,590
|
State Tax: $0
Take Home: $100,000
+$6,410
|
| Cost of Living | New York City ranks among the world's most expensive cities. Manhattan rent for one-bedroom apartments often exceeds $3,000 monthly, with outer boroughs requiring $2,000-2,500. Home purchases in desirable areas frequently surpass $1 million. Property taxes substantial. Sales tax reaches 8.875% in NYC. Dining, services, and general expenses all elevated. Upstate New York offers dramatically better value - Buffalo, Rochester, and Syracuse maintain housing costs 60-70% below NYC levels. | South Dakota consistently ranks among America's most affordable states. Sioux Falls and Rapid City offer small-city amenities with housing costs dramatically below national averages. Quality homes typically sell for $200,000-300,000. Property taxes stay low. Groceries and services cost substantially less than national averages. The extreme affordability combined with no state income tax means even moderate salaries support comfortable lifestyles. |
Pros & Cons
New York
✓ Advantages
- Unmatched career opportunities in finance, media, and technology
- World-class public transportation in NYC reduces car costs
- Cultural amenities and entertainment unavailable elsewhere
- Strong worker protections and employment rights
- Healthcare and education systems among nation's best
⚠ Considerations
- Combined state and city income taxes can reach 14% or higher
- Extremely high housing costs especially in NYC
- Property taxes among highest in America
- Sales tax reaches 8.875% in New York City
- High costs extend beyond rent to groceries and services
South Dakota
✓ Advantages
- No state income tax
- Very low cost of living
- No state estate tax
- Business-friendly
⚠ Considerations
- Cold winters
- Limited metro areas
- Lower average salaries
- Remote location
Bottom Line
South Dakota's no income tax versus New York's 8.82% translates to roughly $6,615 advantage at $75,000. New York stays relevant by offering no income tax. The decision often hinges on whether {factor} or direct tax savings carries more weight in your situation.📢 Share This Comparison
Help others make informed decisions about their paycheck